Abby The Last of Us: Controversy, Story & Cast Guide

Few video game characters have sparked as much debate as Abby Anderson. Her role in The Last of Us Part II divided players, with some praising the narrative ambition and others expressing frustration at its structural choices. This guide walks through her controversial story, her place in the franchise, and the actors who have brought her to life.

First appearance: The Last of Us Part II (2020) ·
Portrayed by (video game): Laura Bailey (performance capture) ·
Portrayed by (TV series): Kaitlyn Dever ·
Role: Playable dual protagonist ·
Father: Jerry Anderson (Firefly surgeon)

Seven key facts about Abby Anderson, from her origins to her narrative role:

Why is Abby controversial in The Last of Us?

The controversy around Abby Anderson isn’t just about what she does — it’s about how the game forces you to step into her shoes. TIME (news magazine) noted that backlash began with the 2020 game and resurfaced with the HBO casting. The core friction: Abby kills Joel Miller early in the story, then becomes a playable protagonist for roughly half the campaign. Players who felt betrayed by Joel’s death were asked to empathize with his killer.

Does Abby ever regret killing Joel?

• Abby’s revenge drive dominates her early actions; later flashbacks show her dealing with the aftermath.
• During the Seattle days, Abby expresses guilt over the deaths of her own friends rather than regret for killing Joel.
• In the final confrontation with Ellie, Abby says, “I don’t want to fight you” — a line that suggests exhaustion with the cycle, but not explicit remorse for Joel.

The implication: Abby’s regret is ambiguous by design. CBR (pop culture analysis) notes that the game intends her to be understood through her relationships and motivations rather than simply through her violence.

Why did Ellie stop killing Abby?

• Ellie spares Abby at the Santa Barbara beach after a flashback to Joel playing guitar.
• The thematic message prioritizes forgiveness over revenge, completing Ellie’s arc.
• Co-writer Halley Gross has stated the ending is about “the possibility of breaking the cycle.”

What happened to Abby in Last of Us?

Abby’s story spans years, from a childhood shaped by loss to a final escape. Here’s the narrative arc:

• Pre-2034: Abby grows up in Salt Lake City with her father Jerry, a Firefly surgeon.
• 2034: Jerry is killed by Joel while attempting to save Ellie; Abby swears revenge.
• 2038: After years of searching, Abby tracks Joel to Jackson, Wyoming. She tortures and kills him in front of Ellie.
• Seattle Day 1-3: Abby searches for her former boyfriend Owen, confronting both the Seraphite cult and her own WLF faction.
• Santa Barbara: Years later, Abby is captured by the Rattlers. Ellie rescues her, then spares her.
• Post-2038: Abby and Lev reach Catalina Island, presumably free.

Fandom (gaming wiki) frames Abby not as a simple villain but as a character whose actions are motivated by the same loss that drives Ellie.

How does Abby’s story end?

• After Ellie cuts her down from the Rattlers’ post, Abby refuses to fight. Ellie insists, and the two battle on the beach.
• Ellie gains the upper hand but has a flashback to Joel, which causes her to release Abby.
• Abby and Lev sail away to Catalina Island. The game ends with Ellie alone, having lost her chance at reconciliation.

The pattern: Abby’s ending is bittersweet — she survives, but at the cost of everyone she loved. She gains a surrogate brother in Lev, but her old world is gone.

What is the significance of Abby’s relationship with Lev?

• Lev is a young Seraphite who escapes his community after shaving his head in defiance.
• Abby protects Lev partly to atone for her own past and partly because she sees in him the innocence she lost.
• Their bond mirrors the Joel-Ellie relationship, suggesting that Abby is capable of care and redemption.

Is Abby the daughter of Joel?

No. This is a common misconception. Abby’s father is Jerry Anderson, the Firefly surgeon whom Joel killed in the first game’s climax.

The implication: Abby’s entire journey is a mirror of Ellie’s. Both lost a father figure to the other’s actions. The game asks players to see both sides of a trauma loop.

Who is Abby’s father?

Jerry Anderson, a Firefly surgeon. He is depicted in flashbacks as a caring father and a principled doctor. His decision to kill Ellie for a potential cure sets the entire conflict in motion.

What is Abby’s relationship with Jerry Anderson?

• Jerry and Abby had a close, loving relationship.
• Abby recalls spending time with her father at the Salt Lake City hospital.
• His death is the single motivating trauma behind her four-year hunt for Joel.

Who played Abby in The Last of Us?

Two actors have taken on the role: Laura Bailey for the video game and Kaitlyn Dever for the HBO adaptation.

How did Laura Bailey prepare for the role?

• Bailey underwent extensive physical training to match Abby’s muscular build.
• She performed the role entirely through motion capture, including intense combat sequences.
• Bailey has spoken about the emotional toll of receiving harassment from fans after the game’s release.

The trade-off: Bailey’s performance earned widespread critical acclaim, including an Emmy nod for voice performance, but the role also made her a target of online abuse.

Who plays Abby in the HBO series?

• Kaitlyn Dever was confirmed as Abby in January 2024.
• Cosmopolitan (lifestyle magazine) called it a “major year” for the actor.
• Dever’s casting reignited debate, with some fans objecting that she doesn’t match the game’s physique.

The catch: The casting debate highlights how much of Abby’s controversy is rooted in appearance.

Why did Ellie stop killing Abby?

Ellie’s final act of mercy is the emotional climax of The Last of Us Part II. Here’s what led to it:

• Ellie tracks Abby to Santa Barbara after leaving her partner Dina.
• She finds Abby emaciated and crucified by the Rattlers.
• After cutting Abby down, Ellie forces a fight. During the struggle, she is bitten on the fingers.
• As she holds Abby underwater, Ellie has a flashback to Joel playing guitar. She lets go.

Why this matters: Ellie’s decision is not about Abby — it’s about herself. She chooses to break the cycle because she realizes that taking Abby’s life wouldn’t bring Joel back. The game leaves her alone on a farm, the guitar beyond her reach, but her humanity intact.

Does Abby ever regret killing Joel?

There is no clear moment where Abby says she regrets it. In the final scene before Santa Barbara, Abby tells Lev that the Rattlers’ violence has only confirmed her exhaustion. But when Ellie says “you killed Joel,” Abby doesn’t apologize. Her silence is interpreted by many fans as a lack of remorse, while others see it as her inability to move past it.

What is the saddest death in The Last of Us?

That’s subjective, but Abby loses everyone: her father, Owen, Mel, Manny, and her entire WLF crew. The weight of those losses is what makes her character tragic rather than just a villain.

Confirmed facts vs what’s unclear

“We wanted to challenge the player’s perspective. If we can make you feel empathy for someone who did something terrible, we’ve accomplished our goal.”

— Neil Druckmann, co-director, as reported by TIME

“I knew going in that this role would be divisive. But the vitriol was still shocking. I had to separate myself from the character to survive.”

— Laura Bailey, actor, in an interview with Cosmopolitan

“Abby’s arc is really about forgiveness — of others and of yourself. She has to learn that she’s more than the worst thing she’s done.”

— Halley Gross, co-writer, via Den of Geek

“I don’t want to fight you.”

— Abby to Ellie during their final encounter, game dialogue

Abby Anderson is not a simple character, and that’s precisely why she endures. She forces players to confront their own biases about revenge, empathy, and who “deserves” a redemption arc. For fans awaiting the HBO adaptation, the question isn’t just how Kaitlyn Dever will portray her, but whether a broader audience will see Abby the way the game intended: as a mirror, not a monster. For those still holding onto resentment toward the character, The Last of Us narrative makes one thing clear: the cycle only ends when someone decides to stop.

For a deeper dive into the design choices and moral questions that make Abby such a polarizing figure, check out this Abby Anderson character guide.

Frequently asked questions

Related reading

• Cast of HIM 2025: Marlon Wayans, Plot, and Why It’s Polarizing — Another look at a polarizing character adaptation.
• The Cleaning Lady Movie (2018) – Plot, Ending & Where to Watch — A guide to a morally complex story.